Negative and positive articles
On the 25th of August, the annual video music awards
(VMA) was aired on the music channel, MTV. The award show had a number of attention
grabbing performances. However there was one performance which seems to be
spoken about up until this day which is the Miley Cyrus performance. Cyrus who has
been a child star on Disney had a whole new different performance singing her latest hit single 'We can't stop' and a Robin Thicke song 'Blurred lines' for the award
show which some have criticized time and time again both praising it and
dissing it.
The Guardian newspaper had a somewhat positive view about the
performance and tried to make Cyrus appear as just another pop artist performer
that was just doing what she felt was expressive. The article made it seem as though
Miley was not to blame for her actions, because what she did was not something
that has not been done time and time again on the VMA stage. The writer also
referred to Lady gaga’s performance and said that what Cyrus has done is not so
different from what Gaga did on the same day.
An article from the Independent on the other hand was not so
appealed by the VMA performance of the pop star, calling the performance all
sorts of names such as racist, disturbing, inappropriate. The article also
outlines the views of the Parents Television Council (PTC) and how they reacted
by issuing a complaint against MTV for airing the pop star’s performance
stating that it should have not been rated suitable for 14 year olds. The article
also draws attention to Robin Thicke who performed alongside with Cyrus and
stated that he should not have reacted the way he did.
References
Walshe. S (2013) 'so Lady Gaga's thong is art, while Miley Cyrus twerking is art?' The Guardian 27th August [online] Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/aug/27/miley-cyrus-twerking-double-standard (accessed at: 13th December 2013)
Wyatt. D (2013) 'the tongue, the twerking the outfit: should someone have stopped Miley Cyrus's performance?' The Independent, 28th August [online] Available at: http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/the-tongue-the-twerking-the-teddy-outfit-should-someone-have-stopped-miley-cyrus-vma-performance-8785494.html (accessed at: 13th December, 2013)